Most of you know that the foods we buy in jars, cans, and boxes typically contain additives to enhance the product’s flavor, texture, and/or shelf life.
In general, the FDA has found these compounds generally safe for consumption and they don’t seem to bother most people. However, the key word here is “most.”
Some people don’t react well to certain food additives, such as MSG and anything in the MSG family (e.g. yeast extract; see my article series on this topic). And recent research has found that emulsifiers and thickeners may not be as safe as once thought, especially for people with gut-related health issues, as I talk about in this article.
After seeing that several people in a food sensitivity forum I belong to report struggles with citric acid, I decided to investigate.
What is Citric Acid?
Citric acid is added to foods to enhance flavor, acidity, and shelf life. This is one of the most common additives around and you’ll find it in all kinds of prepared foods, ranging from fizzy drinks to canned soup, as well as in pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, and cleaning agents.
Citric acid occurs naturally in many fruits and veggies, especially citrus fruits like lemon and lime. However, the citric acid in our canned and bottled foods doesn’t come from fruit or other natural food sources. Instead, it’s manufactured.
History of Citric Acid
This additive has an interesting history, dating back to the 1700s, when the Italians began producing it from citrus. They controlled the world market on the stuff until it got too expensive and others began to search for alternatives.
During WWI, an American chemist began making citric acid using mold. In particular, certain strains of Aspergillus niger (a type of black mold) worked well. This led to industrial production of citric acid, and to this day this is how citric acid is made.
The formula is simple: you feed the mold sugar (in various forms) and it produces citric acid.
Here’s what’s interesting: manufactured citric acid predates the FDA. Because the substance was already being consumed worldwide with seemingly no problems, it got grandfathered in to FDA’s GRAS (generally recognized as safe) status. In other words, no one has tested its safety.
Does Citric Acid Cause Food Reactions?
Many people with tyramine intolerance report that citrus is a strong trigger for them. However, citrus fruits are not high in tyramine, so why does this happen?
It can happen for a few reasons. First, if the fruit has gotten too ripe, that will raise tyramine levels enough to cause a reaction. Fruits need to be fresh for the tyramine intolerant.
Second, if having food sensitivities (and interacting with others who do) has taught me anything, it’s that most people are often sensitive to more than one thing. For example, if you get migraines from tyramine, chances are you will get them from other trigger foods as well.
For me, that other trigger food is wheat (a story I chronicle here). For others, it’s citrus, which is a common migraine trigger.
So, that leads to another question—do people react to fruit-derived citric acid or to the manufactured citric acid? In citrus is a trigger for you, you’ll probably react to both.
However, some people only react to the manufactured citric acid added to foods. Which leads me to:
A Study Examining Inflammatory Reactions to Manufactured Citric Acid
I found an interesting study examining the potential dangers of eating foods with manufactured citric acid.
They conducted four case studies, in which participants with known sensitivities were given foods with manufactured citric acid as well as foods with citric acid derived from citrus fruit. Participants didn’t know they were being exposed to manufactured citric acid, nor did they know that was what was being studied.
The participants experienced inflammatory reactions to the foods containing manufactured citric acid, but not the natural stuff. Their symptoms included joint pain with swelling and stiffness, muscular pain, difficulty breathing, fatigue, and abdominal cramping after ingestion of the foods with manufactured citric acid.
The authors point out that citric acid is citric acid, regardless of whether it comes from lemons or comes from black mold being fed sugar. The molecular structure is exactly the same. So why would people react to one and not the other?
Because the manufactured version may contain impurities or fragments from the black mold during the manufacturing process. Probably okay for many, but not for all.
Digging into the Individual Cases
The case studies themselves (four of them, all different ages and backgrounds) had some interesting things in common. For example:
- The more manufactured citric acid the participants consumed, the worse their symptoms.
- Three of four cases had visited multiple doctors and undergone lots of testing, with zero answers. (Sound familiar?)
- All ended up discovering their sensitivity through elimination diet. Elimination diet is the only reliable test for food intolerance at this time. Food intolerance tests do exist, but they don’t work reliably and don’t work for all sensitivities. See this article for more information on testing, including food allergy testing.
The authors conclude that the Aspergillus niger mold won’t cause problems for many people, but others who are sensitive, allergic to molds, or have a weakened immune system can react badly to it. The authors also state that this mold’s spores can cause reactions even when the mold has been killed (by, say, heating), which means the remnants resulting from industrial production of citric acid will cause problems for some.
The Takeaways
I had several takeaways from his dive into citric acid, which you may find helpful:
- If you’re sensitive to molds, have allergies, or are immunocompromised, I would avoid any food, supplement, or product containing citric acid.
- If you find yourself reacting to any kind of prepared food (anything in a jar, can, or box), check the ingredient list. Look for common ingredients across the products you react to. The culprit could be citric acid, or it could be anything else on that ingredient list.
- As I’ve discussed in my articles on MSG, flavor enhancers, and emulsifiers/thickeners, food additives may be reasonably safe for most, but some of us don’t fall into the “most” category. If you have food sensitivities, limit your consumption of prepared foods as much as possible.
Thoughts? Have any of you experimented with citric acid?
Want to get notified when I publish another article? Sign up here!
Related Articles and Resources
What is Natural Flavor? 6 Facts You Need to Know
Emulsifiers, Thickeners, and Gut Health
DISCLOSURE: This site uses affiliate links, which means the Rogue Scientist may get a commission if you purchase a product through a link. There is no cost to you.
11 thoughts on “Citric Acid: Friend or Enemy?”
Your article describes my experience with citric acid perfectly and well. Thank you for writing this.
Glad to hear it, Jillanna. So many people probably deal with this and don’t know it.
I believe the particles and fragments of the mold are known as the mycotoxins which are the byproduct toxins/gasses left behind that aren’t killed off with the mold. I have been blood tested and have many strains of them in my bloodstream now that I am dealing with. They are what are causing me all the symptoms I currently have. They definitively aren’t easy to detox from. Still looking for help and guidance. Good luck and God bless all of us that are struggling We aren’t alone even though it definitely feels that way much of the time. We need more research, educated Drs and detox treatments for these aggressive mycotoxins.
I have had 3 different experiences with what you are talking about with what I think is a specific citric acid issue. A couple of years ago I was attending an out of state concert and drank a non-alcoholic fruity drink and ended up in the ER with pain in my lungs. Everything checked out okay. This year I have had two different episodes…one after drinking some juice that I had added store bought lemon juice to and then eating some mixed fruit applesauce that had ascorbic acid added to it. Same reaction all 3 times. I do have autoimmune issues, so I am sure that plays into it. Thank you for your well written article addressing this!
My problem with Citric Acid is ,
It’s in after shave / hand cleaner / and many other things that I would like to eat or use .
if I do eat it or use it in any way I become easily bad tempered to the point of aggression .
I’m now 83 fairly fit but would love a Antidote, is bi carb worth trying.
when I was younger it would stop me working for 3 days at a time with violent migraines And caused me a great deal of trouble financially , as long as I keep away from it ( which is very hard to do ) I’m fine .
But mystified as to what it does to me , it appears to attack my nerve system.
Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Christopher Toop.
Yeah, some people really react badly to it, probably to whatever remnants are left from the mold. Not sure if there is an antidote, but would be worth searching a bit or consulting AI to search for you.
I have been told by doctors to watch my citric acid. SODA! I have stopped drinking soda, the exception of maybe a half a glass a week and trying to watch my diet. I was amazed to find out how many products contain citrus acid and then didn’t know if they meant citric acid in fruit. I have been eating oranges blueberries raspberries, bananas apples, and wonder now if I should not be eating those these fresh fruits. I don’t know what to eat now at all. Mostly tuna, eggs, salmon, chicken cottage cheese is my diet. Any suggestions?
For citric acid, it’s the additive in prepared foods that’s the problem, not the natural form in fruit.
Interesting that you say that citrus fruits are not high in tyramine, yet I have seen lists (even AI) that put them in the ‘eat with caution’ category or ‘avoid’. I assume your statement is based on testing, so I wonder where this other idea is coming from, especially when citric acid itself does not contain tyramine. Any thoughts on this confusion?
It’s an interesting question. Citrus fruits aren’t high-tyramine per se, but some sources claim they have tyramine even though I don’t believe that’s the case, since high-tyramine foods get that way due to bacterial processes such as fermentation, aging, ripening, etc. Many people who are sensitive to tyramine report sensitivity to citrus fruits, though, particularly lemon juice. Citrus is a common migraine trigger too. We don’t know why, but I would guess it’s the other compounds in citrus.
I am so happy to have came across this article, after starting to suspect that citric acid might be the cause of the horrible migraines I’ve been experiencing lately. And now that I am aware of it, the MCA seems to be everywhere!! I’ve always loved fruit flavoured sweets and drinks, unknowingly poisoning myself, and for years could not understand my strange aches and pains. I’ve had the standard allergy tests but of course none of them picked up on this.
I have to say that I was horrified to learn that MCA is made from black mold! And I do think that the matter of MCA is something that should be addressed by regulatory authorities, even if it only adds a warning on food items to make people aware.