A lot of people with tyramine intolerance (and related food sensitivity issues like histamine intolerance) don’t do well with certain food additives and preservatives.
For example, many will avoid flavor enhancers such as MSG or anything in the MSG family, such as yeast extract and hydrolyzed vegetable protein. They also tend to avoid preservatives such as nitrates, nitrites, and sodium benzoate.
I try to avoid these myself. I don’t always react to them, but when you have food sensitivities, you learn that it’s easier to avoid “filling the bucket” by staying away from things that aren’t worth the risk. Personally, I would rather eat fresh food and avoid the junk they add to foods. I feel better when I do.
But what about emulsifiers and thickeners? These get added to so many foods, and have always been considered safe, even for people with sensitivities. But now, evidence has emerged that even emulsifiers/thickeners may not be healthy, especially for those with food sensitivities.
So what are these things?
Emulsifiers
According to the European Food Information Council, emulsifiers are food additives used to mix two substances that typically separate when combined. For example, oil and vinegar don’t mix because one is fat-based and the other water-based, which is why almost all salad dressings have emulsifiers in them.
And… so do a LOT of other foods that come in jars and cans. This gives the food a better appearance and texture.
For the scientifically curious, emulsifying agents work because, at the molecular level, they contain both fat-loving and water-loving elements, so they can connect the two when they’d normally avoid each other. They’re basically the dongle of the molecular world.
Examples of emulsifiers include lecithin, polysorbates, and mono- and diglycerides.
Thickeners
Thickeners are added to foods to improve their texture and make them thicker, without altering taste or other properties. You will often find them in sauces, soups, heavy cream, most nondairy milks, ice cream, and a ton of other products.
Many substances serve as both an emulsifier and a thickener, so I’ve combined them into one article. You’ll find that most articles, including research articles, will lump them together as well.
Examples of thickeners include gums (guar gum, xanthan gum, gellan gum), agar, pectin, cellulose (e.g. methylcellulose), and carrageenan.
Are Emulsifiers and Thickeners Safe to Eat?
Generally, emulsifiers and thickeners have been considered safe, even for the more sensitive. Until recently, I never worried about them and I’m a hardcore label-reader who tries to avoid food additives and preservatives.
One reason for the lack of concern is many of these substances are derived from natural things, such as plants (guar gum, lecithin, pectin) or seaweed (carrageenan). Some serve as a form of soluble fiber, which can be a good thing in the diet.
However, in the last few years, research has produced some evidence that emulsifiers and thickeners may disturb the gut lining and create inflammation in the gut.
The Studies
For example, this study in Microbiome looked at 20 different emulsifiers/thickeners and how they impact human gut microbiota (microorganisms). They found that most had a “detrimental impact on microbiota composition and function” and that “Particularly stark detrimental impacts were observed in response to various carrageenans and gums, which altered microbiota density, composition, and expression of pro-inflammatory molecules.”
Another example: In a small randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study, they looked at human patients with ulcerative colitis, an inflammatory disease affecting the colon, but whose condition was in remission. They gave half the group a carrageenan supplement (n=5) and the others a placebo (n=7), and followed them until relapse or one year, whichever came first. Three of the five in the treatment group relapsed while none of the seven in the placebo group did.
These studies have their limitations. The first was conducted ex-vivo (the microbiota were taken out of the body and studied in the lab), so we aren’t sure what would happen IN the body, at least not in this study. The second study has a tiny sample, which limits power to draw strong conclusions. Yet, these studies, along with others I came across, make me question whether emulsifiers and thickeners are worth eating.
Why Does This Matter for Those With Food Sensitivities?
Food sensitivities are still a bit of a mystery for the scientific and medical community, but many believe they result from disturbance in the gut, including the gut lining. This disturbance can happen in a couple of ways:
- Your gut bacteria can’t process the food properly, resulting in symptoms.
- Your gut lining is damaged or compromised, so substances escape the gut and wind up in the bloodstream, resulting in symptoms. This is known as “leaky gut.”
When you think of gut issues, you think of gas, bloating, diarrhea, constipation. But a disturbed gut can affect everything—it can cause migraines, brain fog, mental health issues, arthritis, and numerous other things that don’t result in gut symptoms.
So it makes sense that any substance that disturbs the gut could be a problem for people with food sensitivities. And there’s at least some evidence that emulsifiers and thickeners can impact the number of gut microbiota, cause inflammation, and damage the gut lining.
I’ve cut foods that use emulsifiers/thickeners. I make my own salad dressing at home (or, in a pinch, just use olive oil). I drink cappuccinos with whole milk now. At home, I use a brand of almond milk that has no thickeners. This article lists a few dairy or dairy-like products that don’t have emulsifiers/thickeners.
Will cutting them help you? We have no way of knowing for sure at this point. It’s possible they aren’t that good for you long-term. It’s also possible some people tolerate emulsifiers and thickeners better than others. After all, this is true for milk products, gluten, sugar, and many other things.
If those with food sensitivities are more prone to gut damage, then maybe it’s better to avoid food additives that irritate the gut.
Let me know what you think.
Want to get notified when I publish another article? Sign up here!
Related Articles and Resources
The Truth About Emulsifiers: Are They Destroying Gut Health?
What is Natural Flavor? 6 Facts You Need to Know
The Rogue Scientist’s 3-articles series on MSG
DISCLOSURE: This site uses affiliate links, which means the Rogue Scientist may get a commission if you purchase a product through a link. There is no cost to you.
8 thoughts on “Emulsifiers, Thickeners, and Gut Health”
What brand of almond milk doesn’t have any thickeners???
I gave up emulsifiers 6 years ago when I started having allergic reactions to them. Sadly, they’re in a lot of commercially available gluten free food, because they function as gluten substitutes.
Califia has a “three-ingredients only” version of almond milk that I buy now and again. I also added a link above with an article that lists some other dairy and similar products without them. Here it is: https://nutritionrewired.com/gut-health/gums-in-food-are-they-bad-for-your-gut/
I tested positive for celiac antibodies a few years ago. My only symptoms were a lot of burps after certain meals (i.e. pizza and pasta) and mild lactose intolerance. Since going gluten free, I have found that emulsifiers give me the same symptoms and gluten. This may be very problematic for people who don’t know about them, as most gluten free bread and baked goods is full of emulsifiers like xantham gum (which the Microbiome study you mention found was one of the worst). Interestingly, MSG gives me the same symptoms as well. When I was younger, MSG and lactose (but not gluten) gave me lower GI gas and bloating, but since turning 40, it flows upwards as burps instead.
Interesting how coeliac can cause milder symptoms in one person but non-coeliac wheat sensitivity can cause a migraine in someone else. So much variability. I’m glad you identified emulsifiers/thickeners as an issue. I suspect they’re an issue for many but they don’t know it. You can find gf stuff without them but it’s hard. I eat this quinoa-based bread I really like but it costs a lot and takes forever to toast!
So true. And symptoms among celiacs also vary widely. I read studies that found some people react to less than 5g of flour, whereas others can tolerate much more. I thought I was asymptomatic when I was diagnosed, I think largely because I was baking my own long-rise bread, which didn’t bother me much, because the long-rise breaks down more gluten. It was only when visiting family and eating a lot of store-bought bread that I realized it made me burp. I can also eat spelt with no reaction at all (in Europe, where I live– I don’t know about the US where flour can be different), even though it has gluten. I understand it has shorter chains of gluten that may be broken down before they cause problems. But most/many celiacs can not tolerate spelt. And presumably NCWSs can’t have spelt either?
That’s a good question re spelt. Depends on whether the NCGS is due to gluten or something else in the wheat. Nobody knows for sure yet. You don’t find much spelt in the US. I ate it in Spain a few years ago in the form of crackers, with no obvious problems.
I like to cook and want to thicken things from time to time such as gravy or soup. I have been using tapioca flour as a thickener. Is that a problem?
The studies didn’t look at tapioca or other non-wheat flours, so I’m not sure. Personally, I use non-wheat flours and cornstarch to thicken with no obvious issues.